Best Overall
Retrospec Sedona
Key details
- Fill
- Buckwheat hulls, adjustable
- Size
- 17 x 10.5 x 5.5 in
- Cover
- Cotton, machine washable
- Shape
- Crescent
The Sedona is the least expensive cushion in this group, and it is the one we hand to anyone who has never owned a zafu. Retrospec gets the load-bearing details right: a 17-inch crescent packed with buckwheat hulls, a cotton cover that stays cool through a long sit, and a zippered inner compartment that lets you pull fill out until your hips sit higher than your knees. The crescent narrows at the front, which leaves room for your ankles to settle instead of stacking one on top of the other.
The fill arrives dense, and that is the one thing to plan for. Open the inner zip, take out a few handfuls, and keep them in a bag; what stays behind molds to your seat bones and holds the shape you press into it. We like that the adjustment runs both ways, so a cushion that ends up too soft can be brought back with the hulls you took out.
Cotton cover, machine wash, carry handle, one-year limited warranty: unglamorous details that matter when a cushion rides in a tote between classes. It is not the prettiest thing on this list, and the velvet picks are the ones for a living room. The Sedona is for practice.
Pros
- Lowest price of the cushions here
- Zippered inner compartment tunes the loft
- Cotton cover is machine washable
- Crescent shape leaves an ankle gap
Cons
- Packed tight and hard until hulls come out
Our default pick: firm buckwheat support you can dial in by removing hulls, a washable cotton cover, and the lowest price here.